Confessions of a (Former) Christian Fiction Snob

03 Jan

images[1]I’ve been a fan of audible books for a while now, and recently signed up for another year’s worth of books on (Current “listens” include The Hobbit – J.R.R.Tolkien, The King’s Cross – Tim Keller and another one I’ll mention in a moment).

But this past summer I also discovered, and ergo, I also discovered Christian fiction.  Yeah, yeah, I know – I’m late to the party.  Mind you, some years ago I had read the first of the Left Behind series (aptly titled, Left Behind), but it apparently didn’t capture my attention because I stopped there.  But this past July I took advantage of a free book from Christian audio (they offer one every month) and downloaded The Sword by Bryan M. Litfin.

I was gloriously transported to the world of Chiveis, and lived there for the next couple of months as I also downloaded the other two of Litfin’s trilogy, The Gift and The Kingdom.

The Chiveis trilogy is the story of the earth some 400 years into the future, where the world as we know it has been destroyed by plague and nuclear war, and those left are thrown back into medieval times, a world of swords and horses and parchment. The hero and heroine, Teofil and Anastasia, live in the mighty Kingdom of Chiveis, where the ruins of our civilization are all around, but the Bible and thus Christianity have been lost.

What a story! And it was more than fiction, because when Teo and Ana find a Bible (only the Old Testament – the New Testament has rotted away in the copy they discover) we get to come along discovering God’s word afresh.

And now I confess: lurking in the back of my mind had been a bit of snobbery regarding Christian fiction, so I appreciated what Randy Alcorn, a Christian fiction writer himself, had say about this in an article in World magazine this past year:

Recently, at a party, a Christian leader raved about various novels. When asked about a particular Christian novelist, he replied, “I never read Christian fiction. It’s predictable, sugar-coated, preachy, and poorly written!”

“Can you give some examples?” I asked.

He couldn’t. Not one. He’d last read Christian fiction 20-some years ago. I politely suggested that since he never reads it, his opinion might not be up-to-date and well-informed.

I’ve encountered the same stereotypical comments countless times, often from people repeating what they’ve heard. I read secular fiction, but also enjoy novels with a Christian worldview. I’m part of an online group of 263 Christ-following novelists that started in 1999 with 15 of us. I’ve witnessed firsthand these writers’ dedication to improving their craft. Some of their work, in my opinion, is breathtakingly good.

Amen.  And I apologize for my own earlier foolishness, Randy.  I stand corrected.

It’s funny that as I write this, Diane and I have started listening to The Prince of Tides, by Pat Conroy on our drive back from her sister’s place in Colorado.  I imagine I got it for its rave listener reviews, but I don’t know if we will continue.  Pat Conroy is an amazing writer, to be sure, but two hours into the read, we have descended into an abyss, and I’m not sure I want to keep exploring this dark world.

Mind you, I would never say that all novels must have happy endings (the real world does not).  However, aside from pain and death, as followers of Christ, we know there is also a reality called resurrection.  There is the glorious word redemption. And there is a beautiful concept called grace.  Should I be surprised that Christian writers can  represent these truths better than any others?


Posted by on January 3, 2013 in Uncategorized


4 responses to “Confessions of a (Former) Christian Fiction Snob

  1. Mark Vande Zande

    January 3, 2013 at 7:07 pm

    I’ll be waiting to know more about “The Sword”. I read secular fiction but I think the last Christian fiction I read was the “Left Behind” series. I read all but the last one. My first encounter with Christian fiction was in the Reformed Church when I was about 7 or 8 years old. Pastor read to the kids out of a book written in 1678 by John Bunyan called “The Pilgram’s Progress. A great story of Christian, his journey to the celestial city and his encounters with “Faithful, Hopeful, Talkative and with things such as Great Despare and The Slough of Despond (think I’ve been there). It’s a wonderful story and a great memory.


  2. Jean

    January 4, 2013 at 9:11 am

    I regularly read Christian fiction and there are so many excellent ones. I admit I’ve read sappy, preachy ones, too; but if you find an author like Francine Rivers or the Thoenes or Angela Hunt, you’ll get hooked.


    • rogerknowlton

      January 5, 2013 at 12:02 am

      So you’ve mentioned. Should I check out those authors, or would you say it’s chik-lit?


  3. JoAnn Karls

    January 7, 2013 at 9:32 pm

    I like quite a few Christian authors and really like Francine Rivers, she wrote some really good books like–“The Last Sin Eater”, “The Atonement Child” and “The Scarlet Thread” just to name a few.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: